How do you define a good tutor?

What makes a good tutor

November 17, 2026•7 min read

What Makes a Good Tutor? Perhaps It Depends on Who You Ask.

What makes a good tutor?

It's a question I've been thinking about recently, and the more I think about it, the more I realise just how subjective the answer is.

After all, what I consider to be good tutoring might be completely different from what somebody else considers good tutoring.

And I think that's something worth exploring, particularly if you're thinking about starting your own tutoring business.

Let me share an experience from many years ago, when I was still relatively new to tutoring.

At the time, I knew another tutor who charged considerably more than I did. I was charging around £20 an hour, while he charged £50 plus travel expenses.

He was someone I'd been happy to recommend to other families. I assumed, perhaps rather naively, that everyone who went into tutoring had the child's best interests at heart and wanted to make a genuine difference.

Then came an experience that completely changed my perspective.

An Hour of Tutoring That Achieved... What, Exactly?

My son, Jamie, was studying A-level economics and had missed a lesson in 6th form.

Unfortunately, the topic he'd missed was going to come up in an assessment, so he needed somebody to explain it to him.

I contacted this tutor and arranged for him to spend an hour with Jamie.

When he arrived, he had a pen.

That was it.

Now, I don't believe a tutor needs to arrive carrying a suitcase full of resources. Some of the most effective lessons can happen with very little equipment.

But what happened next was rather revealing.

The tutor asked Jamie what he wanted to work on.

Jamie explained that he needed help with the topic he'd missed.

"Okay, so what do you already know about it?" the tutor asked.

"Nothing really. I missed that lesson."

"Well, you must know something."

"No, I wasn't there. That's why I need help."

And so the conversation continued.

For the best part of an hour.

The tutor kept asking Jamie what he knew, and Jamie kept explaining that he hadn't been taught it.

There was no real attempt to introduce the topic, explain the basic concepts or find another way into the learning.

At the end of the hour, the tutor left.

And Jamie was none the wiser.

But He Thought He'd Done a Good Job

As a parent, I remember thinking, What exactly have I just paid for?

I hadn't expected miracles.

I didn't expect Jamie to become an expert in economics in sixty minutes.

But I did expect him to come away with something.

Perhaps a better understanding of the topic. Perhaps a few key concepts he could revise. Perhaps enough confidence to tackle the assessment without feeling completely lost.

Instead, he was in exactly the same position as he'd been before the tutor arrived.

And that troubled me.

Not just as a parent, but as somebody who was building a tutoring business and recommending other tutors to families.

Because when I recommend somebody, I'm putting my own reputation behind that recommendation.

If a parent trusts my judgement, I want to feel confident that the person I'm recommending will genuinely support their child.

So I contacted the tutor and explained that, unfortunately, I wouldn't be able to recommend him to other families anymore.

His response?

"Well, nobody's ever complained before."

And I think that's where the difference in our perspectives became particularly clear.

From his point of view, he'd turned up, spent the hour with Jamie and provided the tutoring session he'd been booked for.

He considered himself a good tutor.

From my perspective, as the parent paying for that session, my child hadn't gained anything.

And that wasn't good enough for me.

So Who Gets to Decide What Makes a Good Tutor?

That's the interesting question, isn't it?

Is it the tutor, who feels they've delivered the service they were asked to provide?

Is it the parent, who is paying and wants to see their child making progress?

Or is it the child, whose experience of the session might be completely different again?

I think all three perspectives matter.

A parent might consider a tutor brilliant because their child's grades have improved.

Another might value the fact that their child no longer cries when it's time to do maths.

A child might love their tutor because they're patient, make learning enjoyable and never make them feel silly for getting something wrong.

And a tutor might measure success by how well they've explained a topic or how much of the planned work they've covered.

None of those perspectives is necessarily wrong.

But I do think there's something that should sit at the heart of every tutoring session.

Has the child gained something from spending that time with you?

Progress Doesn't Always Mean Getting More Answers Right

One of the things I've learnt over my years of tutoring is that progress isn't always immediately measurable.

Sometimes a child learns how to solve an equation they've been struggling with.

Sometimes they finally understand a grammatical concept.

Sometimes they manage to write a paragraph independently for the first time.

But sometimes the progress is much less obvious.

Perhaps a child who usually refuses to attempt a question has a go.

Perhaps they feel comfortable enough to admit they don't understand.

Perhaps they leave the lesson believing that maths isn't quite as frightening as they thought.

Those things matter too.

And sometimes, despite your best efforts, a lesson doesn't go as planned.

That doesn't automatically make you a bad tutor.

We're working with human beings, after all, not machines.

Children have difficult days. They get tired, frustrated, distracted or overwhelmed. Sometimes the approach you thought would work beautifully simply doesn't.

That's when we need to be willing to adapt.

To stop and ask ourselves whether there's another way to explain something.

To recognise that perhaps the lesson needs to change, rather than expecting the child to change to fit the lesson.

It's something I feel incredibly strongly about.

Tutor the child, not the label.

And I'd go one step further.

Tutor the child, not simply the lesson plan.

What Would You Want a Parent to Say About You?

If you're already tutoring, or you're thinking about starting a tutoring business, I'd encourage you to consider something.

Imagine a parent reflecting on the session you've just delivered.

What would you hope they'd say?

Would they feel their money had been well spent?

Would their child have gained some knowledge, confidence, understanding or reassurance?

Would they feel you'd listened to their child and responded to what they actually needed?

Because I don't believe being a good tutor is simply about having excellent subject knowledge, charging a particular hourly rate or turning up at the agreed time.

Those things may all play a part, but they don't tell the whole story.

For me, it's about making a positive difference, however small that difference might be.

It's about leaving a child in a better position than they were when you arrived.

And it's about being able to finish a lesson knowing you've genuinely tried to give that child what they needed.

Not every lesson will be perfect. Not every child will make obvious progress every week.

But that intention, combined with the willingness to reflect, adapt and keep learning ourselves, is what I believe makes the difference.

Building a Tutoring Business You Can Feel Proud Of

If you're thinking about becoming a tutor, or you're already tutoring but would love some guidance as you grow your business, I'd love to help.

Not simply with the practicalities of finding students, setting your prices or running a business, although those things are important too.

But with building a tutoring business you can genuinely feel proud of.

One where children are treated as individuals, parents feel listened to, and you finish your working day knowing you've made a difference.

Because ultimately, that's what tutoring has always been about for me.

Helping children leave our lessons with something they didn't have when they arrived.

Whether that's knowledge, confidence, understanding or simply the belief that they can do it.

If that sounds like the kind of tutoring business you'd love to build, take a look at the support I offer.

Explore my tutor mentoring and business support

I'd love to help you build something you're proud of.

Dawn Strachan

Dawn Strachan

For the past 20+ years I have been a firm believer that learning should be an enjoyable experience. I appreciate that traditionally education has revolved around worksheets, textbooks, listening to teachers. But a grounding in early years and working with children who had a variety of learning styles from I learned that it is an individual activity that is personal to all of us. We don’t all learn in the same way. Our influences, our experiences, our capabilities all influence how we retain information. But through it all, I believe that if we can make it enjoyable and engaging, they will want to participate. With participation comes practice which in turn boosts skill and confidence. With an increase in skill and confidence comes a willingness to have a go. This in turn leads to more practice which leads to a positive spiral of success. The moral, we need to make learning fun, engaging, use a range of techniques.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog